Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls
These Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls are certainly an old favorite and much better than anything you will find in the candy aisle.
Are there ever enough Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls to go around? I don’t think so. Chocolate and peanut butter is a combination that’s hard to beat, don’t you think? These easy treats are perfect for parties or as a surprise for any chocolate and peanut butter lover. Watch them disappear!
Plus, these Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls couldn’t be easier to make. Really. Dipping treats in chocolate may be intimidating to some, but once you try it a couple of times, it is really very easy. I promise. Be sure to check out the Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls Recipe notes below for all kinds of helpful tips.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls recipe notes:
- Make sure there is room in the fridge for chilling a baking sheet of these. Chilling is important!
- The peanut butter dough can be made ahead, tightly wrapped in plastic and refrigerated for a couple of days until ready to form the balls.
- Finished peanut butter “dough” should be firm enough to make a ball that holds together. Additional powdered sugar (confectioners sugar) may be needed. Just add a tablespoon or so until the correct consistency is reached.
- Warm hands will make the dough soften. If dough begins to soften, return the dough to refrigerator to firm back up for a little while. The same can be said for working in a warm space. If it’s hot where you are, you may need to keep returning the dough to the refrigerator, and/or add more powdered sugar to thicken up dough.
- A wooden skewer or thick toothpick will help for dipping the peanut butter balls in chocolate. Once dipped and excess chocolate has dripped off, slide a fork under the ball (skewer between tines) and pull the skewer out from below, while holding ball with fork. Then use skewer to gently push ball off of fork onto lined baking pan.
- For chocolate dipping, try this tip I learned from my friend, Bakerella. Once dipped in chocolate, while holding the skewered peanut butter ball over container of melted chocolate, gently tap your wrist or hand with your other hand until the excess chocolate drips off. I thought it was an odd thing to tap my wrist or arm instead of just shake the stuff off, until I tried it. Works like a charm!
- Peanut Butter treats always makes me feel sad for those that are allergic to peanut butter. For those with peanut allergies (and those who like almonds) check out these Chocolate Almond Butter Balls.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls Recipe
Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls Recipe
Chocolate and peanut butter are an all-time favorite combo for many of us, plus, these Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls couldn’t be easier to make.
Ingredients:
- 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter (substitute other nut butters, if needed)
- 3 tablespoons salted butter, softened
- 1 cup+ powdered sugar
- 8 ounces semi-sweet chocolate, chopped (or chocolate chips)
Directions:
- Mix peanut butter and butter together in a mixing bowl. Gradually stir in powdered sugar until combined well into a dough ball. If needed, add more powdered sugar a little at a time until mixture holds together in a large ball. Cover and let peanut butter dough sit for about 15 minutes to firm up, or cover tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate until ready to form balls.
- Shape into 1-inch balls, place on a baking sheet, cover and refrigerate for at least 20 minutes to allow to firm up. Dough balls should hold shape before dipping in chocolate. Add more refrigeration time if necessary.
- Melt chocolate according to package instructions.
- Dip peanut butter balls one at a time into melted chocolate, allowing excess to drip off. Place on waxed paper lined baking sheet, cover and refrigerate until ready to serve.
- The peanut butter dough can be made ahead, tightly wrapped in plastic and refrigerated for a couple of days until ready to form the balls. Once peanut butter balls are formed, they can also be covered in plastic wrap ad refrigerated until ready to dip in chocolate.
- Finished peanut butter “dough” should be firm enough to make a ball that holds together. Additional powdered sugar (confectioners sugar) may be needed. Just add a tablespoon or so until the correct consistency is reached. If peanut butter dough seems too soft, tightly wrap dough in plastic and refrigerate for about 20 minutes to firm up before forming balls.
- Warm hands will make the dough soften. If dough begins to soften, return the dough to refrigerator to firm back up for a little while. The same can be said for working in a warm space. If it’s hot where you are, you may need to keep returning the dough to the refrigerator, and/or add more powdered sugar to thicken up dough.
- If concerned with peanut allergies, substitute an almond butter or other nut butter that is allowed for the peanut butter.
Originally published January 24, 2014.
I’m tickled that you’re here! Like you, I wear many hats, and live to tell about it. This space is a place for sharing food, home, garden, travel and lifestyle tidbits, with some fun always thrown in for good measure.
Wow, this recipe is really easy and looks delicious!!!
They are easy, and kinda fun to make too. Nothing like playing with chocolate and peanut butter!
You can add some rice krispies and skor too 🙂
Stunning photography and I’ll take at least a dozen 🙂 Pinned!
Hello Averie,
Thank you! You are too sweet. I’ll have three dozen waiting for ya. We’ll have a peanut butter ball party!
Yummy! Thanks for the recipe! It’s on my to make list!
Yay! Let me know how they turn out.
I’m allergic
Soooo I was just on twitter and I am Never on twitter and these were all up in my face! They are amazing and I am starving and I may consider ditching everything I am supposed to be doing right now to make them happen
Hello Heather!
I’d say that’s a great idea! 😉 What could be better than playing with chocolate and peanut butter?
Peanut Butter Balls are one of my favorite things in the world. YUM!
Mine too, Robyn! And Randy’s … and Hope’s … Hank, not so much. Can you believe that?!?
There is never enough peanut butter balls! Love these, Amy! They look delicious!
Howdy Tieghan,
No, there don’t seem to be enough of them. And as easy as they are to make, I’m afraid. Real afraid.
These look so simple and so delicious! I’d totally try them with almond butter, too.
Pinning!
Abbie,
Let me know how you like them with the Almond Butter. And what about making cashew butter and using that? Whoa.
Peanut butter balls are the best! So good!
Hello Jessica!
They are a favorite for so many. Dangerously good.
LURVE these! They’re just like my beloved buckeye but BETTER!
I know! We should get together sometime and make more! Like a ton of em.
They are delicious and so simple and that earns them a spot in my cookies and candies Christmas baskets oh so yummy
These are some of my favorite treats!! Love!
They’re some of our favorites too, Katrina. I just need to be able to banish them from my mind for a while so I don’t keep making them. So easy and so good.
I skipped Christmas; a move was in order and though so happy to be in my new home, I’m sort of craving some of those treats I totally missed. Then this shows up. I could easily take a cue from Heather and play hooky with everything else today and make these. So yum.
Hey there Barbara,
I’ve been feeling the same way, and just had to take some time to bake and chill. It’s therapeutic, don’t ya think?
Glad to hear about your happy new home! Congratulations!
Your photos are just awesome – had to stop by and say that 🙂 Can’t wait to try these!
Hello Ashley!
Thank you so much. So glad you stopped by. That made my day! 🙂
These would be so dangerous in front of me because I’m pretty sure I’d eat the entire tray!
Susan, don’t ask how many I’ve eaten. Just don’t.
Thank you Jenny!
They a favorite—a dangerous favorite—around here. Oh my word …
We started making these during the holidays. My son has a peanut allergy so we used WOW Butter. Oh my gosh….soooo good! Tastes so much like Reeses (even without real PB) We also used chocolate almond bark for the coating.
Oh wow! That does sound marvelous, Alison. And a chocolate almond bark coating … great idea!
Whoa…I could pop every single one of those in my mouth right now! Cannot wait to make these! I have to tell you…I just adore the way you styled that shot and the type…it’s perfect!
Thank you so much Caroline! It was a fun recipe to make AND eat. They were dangerous to have around. So good!
Hey there.
Quick question-does the butter have to be salted? These look so amazing, but I only have unsalted butter on hand.
Thanks!
Unsalted is great! If you’d like, add a pinch or two of salt to taste.
These look fantastic Amy! 🙂
Quick question: what did you use do dip them in the chocolate?
I think i’m going to make these for the Superbowl on Sunday!
Natalie, I used a wooden toothpick. A skewer would work well too.
Thanks Amy. These turned out incredible! Thank you for sharing this recipe! 🙂
So glad to hear it!
I just made these..they were so good. My husband and son loved them. I had to hide them in the refrigerator so they last a few days!..lol! Thank you for the recipe.
Yay! I’m so glad you enjoy them. I know what you mean about hiding them. 😉 They are seriously a test for self-control.
These look amazing and I’m trying to make them right now but the dough won’t let me roll it it falls apart :0
If the dough is soft, cover it tightly and place it the refrigerator until it firms up.
Pingback: Chocolate Peanut Butter Footballs Recipe - She Wears Many Hats
These look great going to make them right now 🙂
I’ve been making chocolate PB balls for 25 years. I love them. The recipe I was given for the dipping added a small amount of paraffin wax to keep the chocolate glossy and kept them firmer longer without a mess in your hands.
I now omitted the wax because I’m not sure how safe it is to eat.
Does anyone have any ideas on how to keep the chocolate firmer?
Use the chocolate for dipping pretzels. It’s in the baking section of your grocery store. I microwave it and dip the balls.
These are so yum-azing! This review is from someone in love, obsessed and constantly eating peanut butter. Other recipes I have used call for too much sugar, the depth of peanut butter is unfairly toned down. I did not make any changes to the recipe itself, only to one of the methods. I do not have a double boiler so I made due with a pyrex bowl affixed atop of a pot filled with water. The only issue with that was it took longer to melt the chips but other than that it worked great.
I am thinking about dusting them in peanut chips next time? Slivered almonds? Coffee grounds?
Thank you Amy! This recipe has helped me wear my “chef” hat proudly!
Done properly these are Buckeyes. Nothing wrong with this way either 🙂
Peanut butter balls are peanut butter balls, and buckeyes are buckeyes. Each done in their own way is “done properly”.
I would like to know what you think about freezing these, I would like to make them in advance to cut back on time right at my event…
I’m not positive about freezing them, but I think they should do okay. The chocolate may change color a bit or get that funky hazy thing that happens sometimes when chocolate is frozen. Maybe if you have time to try a few to test, that would be the best? If you do, please let me know how they turn out. It would be very helpful to freeze a bunch before the holidays and then hide them in the back so they don’t disappear.
CAN MERKANCE CHOCOLATE BE USED TO DIP THEM IN
Merckens melting chocolate is perfect for these.
Thank you Amy
Did anyone ever try to freeze these? How did it work
I haven’t tried to freeze them yet, but let me know if you do.
My family has made peanut butter balls for years, mostly as a holiday treat, but we always freeze them so we can eat them throughout the year. They freeze amazingly well, and actually that’s now my favorite way to eat them.
Add rice krispies to the recipe. I make buckeyes with them and it’s like heaven in a little ball.
Oooh … YUM! That sounds like one crispy sweet treat! Thanks for sharing, Catherine.
Can you substitute the creamy peanut butter for crunchy peanut butter??
Do you mean substitute crunchy for the creamy? The recipe calls for creamy peanut butter, but you may substitute crunchy.
These look delicious! I think I will make these for the holiday work get together. Thanks for sharing!
They’ll be perfect for a work party!
My Granny made these with me every Christmas on our “Christmas baking day”…. I made them with my children as they grew up and now I am sharing them with my husbands Mother. We have our renewed the “Christmas baking day” I can’t wait to share these with my grandchildren as well!
That sounds like a wonderful tradition! I’m hoping to have a baking day as soon as our kids are out of school for Christmas break. Y’all have fun!
has anyone tried using margarine, instead of butter? Wanted to make them dairy-free…
These have been made for years in my family and I can guarantee we’ve never paid attention to whether is was butter or margarine…cannot tell the difference.
My recipe except I add 1 cup graham cracker crumbs in! Amazing!!!
Oh yum! I’ll try to remember to try it with the graham crackers next time.
My husband asked for peanut butter balls as part of my annual Christmas cookie swap with my girlfriend. Came across this recipe and it couldn’t have been easier. My slight modification — colored Sea Salt (red/green) and sprinkled a little on the top. So good. Thanks
How fun is that?!? Did you color the sea salt yourself or find it somewhere?
Just made 6 dozen of these for Christmas gifts. Dipped 3 dozen in chocolate and 3 dozen in white chocolate.. Super easy recipe and they are absolutely delicious! ! !
You are a Peanut Butter Ball machine! I bet they were gorgeous.
In the old old family recipe I had that too called for wax parafin. To add to the chocolate so it gave th chocolate a nice shine. And I do. Soooo very much Thank u cause I don’t no where it went to. . So I’m very thankful that you posted this… and YES… I’ve also Frozen them befor too… but if everyone loves them witch I’m pritty sure they will… you’ll have to hide them too in th freezer. .. I used to hide mine in a bag empty washed out bag of Sprouts..lol.. or a veg that NO ONE. IN my family liked. …caus if ya don’t hide them..then they’ll find em and eat them all.. once I made quite a few dozen.and I planned on giving them to my friends for xmas. .well I went to get them out of th Freezer to put them in nice boxs… and there was at least over 12 dozen wen I put them in therr. And Omg.???? there where only abt 6. Of them left in there… I was Soooo upset with my kids and fella for rating nearly ALL of them. I just thought I’d share this with you.
I like your idea of camoflauging the packaging to hide them!
I use a small ice cream, or butter scoop to make these balls, I then freeze them on a cookie sheet, then put them in a plastic bag in the freezer. I have a small glass container that I keep almond bark in. When I need some of these little goodies I just go to the freezer take out what I need, melt the bark in the micro-wave, (I set the ball on a fork over the glass container and spoon the bark over the ball. Since it was frozen the bark solidifies immediately.) This is great for a quick thank you gift, easy and frugal.
Great technique! Especially if you just want a couple to enjoy at a time.
I have made these for my family for over 30 years. It is one they anticipate and look forward to every Christmas!
Hi. So, I just made these peanut butter balls. I doubled the recipe as I am selling them at a 1st grade bake sale. They are good but seem really really really sweet. And I used natural peanut butter. Are they supposed to be so sweet? Also how do you melt the chocolate to get really good coverage? I melted chocolate chips and it was very thick. I skewered the ball and dipped half of it, then had to spread the rest on. I used milk chocolate.
Thanks.
Kelsey
They are a sweet treat! You could adjust sweetness as desired, if you’d like. Of course, milk chocolate will be sweeter than a semi-sweet chocolate. As far as melting the chocolate, I melted the chocolate according to package instructions. I used semi-sweet chocolate for these. I’m not sure if milk chocolate would cover any differently. A trick that may help if the chocolate is too thick for you, is to add a bit of coconut oil (the kind that is solid at room temperature) or vegetable shortening to the melted chocolate to thin it out. Just a little at a time, a couple of teaspoons at a time until it’s to your preference.
I edited my previous response to clarify that for thinning out the melted chocolate for dipping, if using the addition of coconut oil make sure it’s the kind that is a solid at room temperature or use vegetable shortening, not vegetable oil. Sorry for any confusion.
Pingback: Chocolate Almond Butter Balls Recipe - She Wears Many Hats
Mmmmm these were fantastic!
I added some coconut oil in with the chocolate to help the coating harden up nicely. Great recipe!! Thanks 🙂
Approximately how many CPB balls will this recipe make?
My mom use to make these. You can def freeze. She used the parfin wax as well. One thing she did was squares just as yummy 1/2 the time. Spread the pnut butter mixture in to a oven pan and poor chocolate over and spread set in freezer for about an hour then cut into squares.. She would make tons of squares and leave in freezer in Tupperware bowl and take out as needed….
Those sound delicious and easy, Carolyn!
Wow I just read ur comment abt u making th chocolate peanut butter balls and adding them to ur xmas baskets… wat a great idea. Who doesn’t love candles.and chocolates. And I Lov th chocolate peanut butter balls. I’m so glad I found this site..caus I had lost my recipe for chocolate
How long do you think i could keep these stored? I love these but i’m trying to make things in advance for a baby shower on the weekend, lots to bake so i figured i’d make these early. Going to try hard not to eat them lol
How long do your think they will stay fresh in the fridge?
They should be okay in the fridge for about 3 days. I have seen others mention that they freeze well, but they never last long enough around here to make it to the freezer. Happy entertaining, Ashley!
I have had these stored in my fridge for about 3 weeks in an airtight container and they stay perfect. I make for Christmas every year and the kids always come back in the new year for refills. They eat the ones in their candy boxes right away because they know Mom has more in her fridge. 🙂
They look fabulous! Stumbled upon this and went to the store to get the ingredients! It’s a must make!!
I hope you enjoy them, Mollie!
Can I freeze the peanut butter balls ahead so I can dip later?
Yes, you can. Just keep them covered with plastic wrap or in a ziptop plastic bag.
How long will they keep in the frig? I am making some today for a party on the 18th. I am really going to try to not keep eating them.
I’m not sure they will last as long as the 18th refrigerated. You can freeze them in a ziptop plastic bag.
How long will they stay good storing in the freezer?
I love the photography. These looks very yummy. Going to make them tomorrow with the kids. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
Do these have to be stored in the refrigerator or would they be okay stored at room temperature? I would like to give them as a gift and would like to have them wrapped up if possible..
They should be okay stored at room temperature, assuming it’s not a hot room.
My grandmother made these when I was a little girl, and I loved them. However, I improved on the recipe by using cashew butter, and chopped cashews. Everybody wants more and I can’t stop eating the darn things.
That sounds delicious, Shirley! I’ve also made these using almond butter (recipe is here on the site) and I kind of like them better.
How many do you get out of one batch? I live in Norway, and are going to make these for christmas.
Absolutely cannot wait to make these for my love and his family! He loves peanut butter 🙂
I hope y’all enjoy them, Kathryn!
They were delicious!!! Made some for my coworkers, and was told how wonderful they were! Thank you!
I’ve lost my old recipe for peanut butter balls! They had the same basic ingredients as this recipe but they also had chopped walnuts or pecans, chopped dates and chopped candied cherries. These added flavors made it hard to stop eating them! I just can’t seem to remember the quantities. I guess there’ll be a few extra batches being made this year until I can get it right.
Help I doubled the recipe and the peanut butter mixture is super sticky. Should I just put it in the fridge for a bit? I’ve added extra powdered sugar.
Yes, I would try to firm it up a bit by letting it cool down in the fridge.
Thank you! I did add some extra icing sugar and refrigerated. They turned out wonderfully! The best I’ve ever had ????
Yay! Happy to hear you enjoyed them as much as we do, Ceri.
Loved this recipe and decided to try a new and exciting difference. Half creamy peanut butter and half cookie butter. We are callng them Peanut Cookie butter Balls!
Oh wow! That sounds fabulous, Tara.
I love these!!!!!! Yay!
Random side note.. To thicken peanutbutter dough, unlike using a brand called PB2 it is powdered peanutbutter!!!!! Will thicken like the sugar without adding more sweet!!!
So love these tho!!! Nom nom nommmmmm!
I like… Stupid fingers got excited
Just made these twice and they turned out terribly. The melted chocolate was much to thick, and the balls fell apart while being dipped. On the second try I spooned chocolate onto the balls, which worked okay but 8 oz was not nearly enough chocolate chips to cover them, and when they were done, they didn’t even taste very good. Much too sweet, gross! Will be finding recipes elsewhere in the future.
Maybe it was your error and not the recipie. Just sayin.
I just made some and they are awesome!! I used a hole bag of chips and put peanuts in the left over chocolate spread on a sheet. Double peanut Christmas snacking pleasure!! Thanks for the guidance!
I made h dough for these the day before Xmas eve and never dipped them. The dough is still wrapped in plastic and in my fridge. How long do you think the dough lasts??? I’m unsure if I should use this dough or make a new batch. Thoughts?
Hmmm … I’m not exactly sure how long it lasts, but I would make a new batch.
Just a thought…..If it were me I wouldn’t worry so much about the “dough” going bad in the fridge. Peanut butter and sugar sit on our shelves ….how long? If there were raw eggs or milk in the recipe I would be concerned, but not with just the three ingredients listed in the recipe for the dough. So glad i found this recipe! It’s been a few years since I have made pb balls and can’t find my old recipe!!!
THANK YOU!
This will be my 4th time making these. Thank you so much much for the recipe. I use natural peanut butter. Crunchy works well also. They keep well in the freezer.
I have made these at Christmas for more than 20 years. Mine also have crushed Rice Krispies in them. I usually double or triple and have made as many as 250 at a time. I roll them and put them on waxed paper lined sheets and freeze them overnight. Then I dip them when froze and it goes super fast. I then put them back in freezer to set. I always store in freezer and they will keep at least 6 months
Wow. These look so easy and I like that the ingredient list is simple!
Have made your bacon onion dip for the past 2
SuperBowls, and it is awesome! This year I saw the chocolate/peanut butter footballs & decided to mix it up a bit.
#EpicFail.
The refrigerated PB mixture was firm enough to hold shape, but was no match for the warm chocolate. I put the formed PB balls in the freezer for maximum “stamina.”
I used semi-sweet Nestle chips melted using a double-boiler, but the chocolate was WAY too thick to effectively dip the 1-inch footballs without them coming off the toothpick… not to mention the copious amount of chocolate retained on each ball. Will definitely have to find a way to thin the chocolate if a second attempt is made (I have an aversion to coconut). Seemed like an easy & delicious addition to the SuperBowl party, but my finished project wasn’t party worthy.
Great recipe thank you! Made these yesterday for Valentines Day. This was my first attempt at chocolate dipped anything lol. I melted Lindt dark chocolate, put the dough in the freezer for 15 instead so it was a bit firmer, and substituted the sugar for powdered coconut sugar and they came out SO good! Will def make again, cheers !
Please email me the recipe