Members Only
This post may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Have you ever met my husband, Randy?
Maybe you’ve read his post about a memory from his younger years as a boy growing up on a farm, or marveled at his talent as the Singing Muffin Man, or the hand behind Slocum, the singing puppet shadow dog? Maybe? Well, if not, he’s back to share some thoughts with you today.
Enjoy!
I’m on the hunt these days for a retailer who will sell me some stuff at a decent price without trying to set me up with one of those stinkin’ bonus or rewards cards. It never fails, I try to run in to grab some shaving cream, herbicide, and peanut M&M’s, then the nice clerk rings me up, and kindly asks, “Are you a member of our rewards club?”
I’ll admit, that question hits close to home. You see I didn’t have the means to own a Members Only jacket back in the day and it still stings. A small part of me wants to be a member of a club, for a little redemption.
Next comes the, “Would you like to sign up today and receive a 20% discount?”
It’s not like I can refuse. I’d feel like such a snob leaving 20% on the table. Plus that Scots Irish frugality runs awfully deep.
Wising up I reply, “How about you give me the discount and I keep my anonymity?”
“Silly man. It’ll only take a minute. Just give us your SS# and mobile phone number, and I promise we won’t compromise your privacy. We’ll just track your spending and eating habits and constant whereabouts so we can serve you better.”
I usually relent then feel dirty afterward.
Instead, this is how it should work…
Mr. Retailer, we’ll engage in a mutually beneficial business transaction. I’ll give you my money in exchange for your stuff and I get the lowest price without regard to my club affiliations. That’s as far as I’ll go. I may or may not come back to your store. We’re all free agents here.
Who’s with me?!?
And while I’m at it, how would I keep up with all those key chain things with the bar codes anyway? I’m certainly not going to put them on my key chain. What goes in your pocket says a lot about who you are: pocketknife, Chapstick, tire gauge, quail feather. I don’t want to be reminded every time I take my car keys out that, yes, I’m a Food Trough® Club Member. No thank you Mr. Retail Store. I’m just not that into you.
So here’s what I’m thinking. Next time some store tries to snag me into their rewards program, I’m going to present the store manager with my own store loyalty application. In exchange for the store completing my application, including the SS# and mobile phone number of the company CEO, I’d be willing to pay the asking price for the items in my shopping cart. If they refuse to complete the form, I’ll offer to pay only 80% of the value in my cart.
What’s good for the goose? No?
I’ll let you know how it goes.
~ Randy
I so agree with you! I can’t fit all of those things on my key chain and they clutter up my wallet. Just give me the discount and i will be a loyal customer.
I think that you would have rocked a Members only jacket 🙂 I know what you mean though and I agree wholeheartedly.
Funny man. 🙂 And sweet to fill in for Ms. Thang while she gets her groove back!
Agreed!! Just think of all the time and COST they expend to track all of us. Really? So we can save? Uh, somehow that just doesn’t add up and I also get so tired of the “Would you like to save 15% on your purchase today at Target by opening an account. No Thank You. Yes I feel like a schmuck but no I don’t want to give the clerk my information either.
I did enjoy you post. Thanks to “the husband” for sharing and looking forward to the updates.
Really great post. You have a really good point – and whats funny, as I read this I think, heck, even my iPhone lets people know where I am and what I’m doing. It’s like a mini GPS tracker. Seriously, I don’t think you should have to hold a card to get a deal. Its insane….and all those cards just cause clutter…and the very few that I have, I can hardly ever find anyway because I can’t carry them in my wallet and won’t carry them on my key chain!
I laughed out loud. Man, talent runs deep in your family! Awesome photography, singing, writing… you do it all! 🙂
You sound just like my husband. We’re definitely with you!
Love.It. My favorite grocery store around here, HEB, does not have rewards cards. And that makes me very happy. If I have to run in to the “other” store, known as KROGER, it just drives me batty having to get out that little card. I thought I had ’em all fooled in the last town where we lived. I gave them a fake phone number when I applied for the card. Then I lost my card. “Don’t worry ma’am, we’ll look up your account with your phone number.” Note to self: don’t forget fake phone number.
Amen!!
HA ! I’m with you on this and laughed at the way you expressed thoughts I’ve had on this very same subject. Hope Amy’s feelin’ better and you’re doing the grocery shopping while she’s recovering. I’m sure the clerks fight over who gets to check you out!
Hahaha, this is BRILLIANT! This made my day. And who’s organized key chain is that a picture of? Impressive all around.
UGH! I hear ya! Drives me crazy. It has been a good lesson in frugality for my kids though. “Why wouldnt you take the 20% mom?” Why don’t you want the “free” credit card….seriously child NOTHING is free in this life. I think your post will hit a nerve with alot of people. ; )
I LOVE it!!……..I so often will tell the store NO, and they look at you like you have 2 heads! I’ve decided to only do it for stores I actually shop at often.
It’s funny, we had a retail store for 15 years, and the last few years I was simply SICK of playing this game….what hoops can we come up with to get people to buy? Why can’t we just stick an open sign in the door, and people will come in and buy? We marked our items with great prices to begin with. But every Jane that walked in, wanted some sort of “deal”……….does the general public NOT realize these stores are marking up their prices so you can get these deals? and who is it hurting? the people NOT getting the memberships……GAHHH!!
I’m with ya Randy!!
I’m with ya Randall!
I’m with you, Randy! Let’s do this!
I just got hit up to apply for a store card yesterday. I feel the same way – why can’t you just give me that price without asking me to give up a kidney, my spending habits, and my mother’s maiden name? I usually reply, “Oh, sorry. Can’t do it. I’m WAY over my head in credit card debt!” Wrapping it up with a nervous laugh puts a nice bow on it. It’s not true, of course, but they don’t need to know that.
PS – If you get enough positive feedback, can we start a club and have Members Only jackets made?
Loved it!! I never can keep track of the cards anyway….so I just give them my phone number to look it up. A lot handier…but yeah, they have my number. Thankfully NOT my cell number. Our home phone rarely rings anymore anyway. 🙂
OH yeah….and I am SO happy that my grocery store doesn’t have them….LOVE Publix for many reasons including this!!
Love this post, Randy! This is one of the many, many reasons I love Publix so much. They don’t mess with that stuff. 🙂
I wish you luck, my friend! Let me know how it goes. I totally agree with you but wanted you to know as well that when you do cave, you can use your handy dandy iPhone (if you have one) to store your cards and just show this to your retailers when they need your card:
http://mycardstar.com/
That way your keychain is free 🙂
Haha! This surely made my day! Reward cards are so overwhelming! It takes ages to accumulate enough points to at least redeem. That way, I love Publix. BOGO sales are the way to go 🙂